J. Edgar (2011)Clint EastwoodDrama / Crime
J. Edgar poster
Movie review

J. Edgar

2.5/5

An imposing historical figure gets a timid prestige biopic

Clint Eastwood’s J. Edgar finds flashes of feeling beneath the prosthetics, but struggles to turn Hoover’s fascinating life into compelling drama.

Jump to review
Directed byClint Eastwood
Release dateNov 11, 2011
Runtime2h 17m
GenreDrama / Crime
Where to watchBuy or rent

An imposing historical figure gets a timid prestige biopic

This review is part of the Reviews On Reels 2011 Rewind series, dedicated to revisiting films in the context of their release. The 2011 Rewind is a work in progress, and more films will be added as they are reviewed.

See all 2011 reviews

Overview

Playing a historical American figure under layers of prosthetic makeup in a film exploring his possible homosexuality, written by a recent Oscar winner and directed by none other than Clint Eastwood? Leonardo DiCaprio was clearly hungry for an Oscar in 2011.

Framed around an aging J. Edgar Hoover (DiCaprio) dictating his memoirs, J. Edgar follows the future FBI director from 1919, when the 24-year-old is put in charge of the Justice Department’s new intelligence division, through the 1960s, when he keeps secret recordings of the Kennedys and Martin Luther King Jr. We watch this determined, ambitious man transform a small, disorganized bureau into a national institution, championing fingerprint identification and forensic laboratories while making himself its public face. In private, he still lives with his mother (Judi Dench), trusts his secretary Helen Gandy (Naomi Watts) to safeguard his personal files, and spends nearly every day with his deputy Clyde Tolson (Armie Hammer), sharing a bond whose true nature, in that era, could have ended both their careers.

Background

The project began with producer Brian Grazer, who developed it at Universal under the title Hoover and brought screenwriter Dustin Lance Black aboard in 2008, before Black won an Oscar for Milk (2008). Black researched Hoover through biographies and interviews with former FBI agents and retired government workers, some in their 80s and 90s. Eastwood became attached to direct, with DiCaprio subsequently entering talks to star, but Universal ultimately passed. The project found a home at Warner Bros., provided the filmmakers could keep costs down. No problem for Eastwood, who had built a reputation for efficient filmmaking, or DiCaprio, who reportedly accepted $2 million instead of his usual $20 million fee. Eastwood shot the film in just 39 days, bringing it in under budget at $35 million. Positioned as an awards contender, J. Edgar opened AFI Fest in November 2011 and became a moderate box office success, but despite Golden Globe and SAG nominations for DiCaprio, and a supporting actor SAG nomination for Armie Hammer, the film received precisely zero Oscar nominations.

Still courtesy of Warner Bros. Pictures Canada

The Review

On its own, the film isn’t necessarily bad, just predictably superficial. Like most prestige biopics, it is far more interested in its actor than in its subject, whose greatest achievements are mostly dramatized in a highlight-reel style. The usual ‘Wikipedia page brought to life’ approach. Seeing how Hoover landed his first job, how quickly he became director, and even the Lindbergh kidnapping, where the Bureau’s forensic methods were first put to use, are by far the least interesting parts of the film, which reconstructs the period and introduces us to the important names without ever giving us a reason to care. We get glimpses of how Hoover manipulated public figures with his recordings while, in parallel, we watch the presidents change, and eventually the country with them, all with very little dramatic weight.

As a history lesson, the screenplay is also considerably incomplete, taking dramatic liberties for the benefit of the character study. The film gives the impression, for example, that after a certain point Hoover only held on to his position through blackmail, ignoring how popular he was with the public. It also strangely barely addresses the FBI’s systematic persecution of gay people, which, given the film’s main focus, is quite puzzling.

Much of the film is built around Hoover’s alleged homosexuality, mainly around how he was forced to repress his desires. Since it was never historically confirmed, the film walks around some of the most revealing claims, trying hard not to offend either side. Hoover’s possible cross-dressing is limited to a single scene in which he puts on his mother’s clothes after her passing, while the relationship between Hoover and Clyde Tolson is portrayed as one between eternal platonic lovers who were never able to embrace their love. Yet it is in those scenes, like when his mother coldly says she would rather have a dead son than a “daffodil” for a son, that the film is at its most effective, briefly making one of the country’s most powerful men seem utterly helpless.

While that scene is by far the best in the film, its impact is not truly felt throughout the rest of it, mostly because of very poor writing and choices in the relationship between Hoover and Tolson. For every scene that barely works between the two, like Tolson’s interview, in which he instantly sees through the farce Hoover is putting on, there are many terrible ones, like Tolson childishly declaring that the two can never miss a dinner together, or the fight that culminates in their kiss. It doesn’t help that Hammer has some truly awful scenes, initially embodying the character’s confidence and charisma, but becoming increasingly one-dimensional and unbelievable as the film goes on.

The worst, of course, are his older scenes, where the actor wears some of the worst prosthetics ever seen in cinema, far more fitting for an Indiana Jones villain after a religious encounter than an old man suffering from a stroke. These were meant to be the film’s most impactful scenes, where Tolson points out how many of Hoover’s stories are invented, or where Hoover finally confesses his love, but they come across almost like an SNL sketch.

As Hoover, DiCaprio is mostly fine, although the Oscar snub was certainly a blessing in disguise (a win would have aged far worse than his eventual victory for The Revenant). He is not entirely convincing, never fully disappearing into the role or feeling intimidating. His best moments are by far the dramatic ones, most obviously with Judi Dench, but also around the other women in his life, like Watts’s Helen and Lea Thompson in a welcome cameo.

The desaturated cinematography serves its purpose, making the film feel like a lost relic, but it also makes it flat and dull to look at, while the score, also by Eastwood, is sparse and often sleep-inducing.

Final Thoughts

J. Edgar is mostly an efficient and respectable biopic, but ultimately uninteresting and inert. It is at its worst in prestige Oscar-bait mode, as compelling as reading a history book, although far less trustworthy, but shows potential when exploring Hoover’s personal secrets, even if it rarely goes beyond surface level. A moment or two might be touching, especially the scenes between Hoover and his mother, but one can’t help being frustrated by the lost potential of a more fascinating character study of a despicable but tortured man.

Still courtesy of Warner Bros. Pictures Canada

At a glance
2.5/5
“UNDERWHELMING”
#2 of 8 in 2011 Movies RankedSee the ranking →
Original title
J. Edgar
Where to watch
Rent or buy at Apple TV Store, YouTube, Amazon Video
Where to watch
Rent or buy at Apple TV Store, Amazon Video
Cast
Leonardo DiCaprio, Armie Hammer, Naomi Watts, Josh Lucas, Josh Hamilton, Judi Dench, Geoff Pierson, Gunner Wright
Rated
R
Crew and more details
Screenwriter
Dustin Lance Black
Composer
Clint Eastwood
Cinematography
Tom Stern
Editor
Gary D. Roach, Joel Cox
Country
Language
English
Budget
$35 million
Box office
$84.606 million
Distributor (CA)
Warner Bros. Pictures Canada
Trailer
Play trailer