The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn – Part 1 (2011)Bill CondonAdventure / Fantasy
The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn - Part 1 poster
Movie review

The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn – Part 1

0.5/5

The worst film of the Twilight franchise is coincidentally its most faithful.

Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson try not to laugh through Breaking Dawn – Part 1, the slowest and most troubling entry in the Twilight saga.

Jump to review
Directed byBill Condon
Release dateNov 18, 2011
Runtime1h 57m
Where to watchDisney+ / Netflix / Crave

The worst film of the Twilight franchise is coincidentally its most faithful.

This review is part of the Reviews On Reels 2011 Rewind series, dedicated to revisiting films in the context of their release. The 2011 Rewind is a work in progress, and more films will be added as they are reviewed.

See all 2011 reviews

Overview

Only the Twilight saga could get away with a film that involves sexual violence and pedophilia (with a baby, no less!) while still being deemed romantic by its target audience. The fourth entry in the franchise, Breaking Dawn – Part 1, follows Bella (Kristen Stewart) through her long-awaited wedding to eternal teenage vampire Edward (Robert Pattinson), which her best friend and crush, Jacob (Taylor Lautner), is not happy about. Bella wants to have a pleasurable honeymoon, which means not turning into a vampire just yet. After a few eventful nights, she discovers that she has gotten pregnant, something that is not only unforeseen in human-vampire relationships, but also extremely dangerous for the girl, as the baby starts consuming her body from the inside. Concerned about what the baby might become, Jacob’s wolf pack starts to plan an attack on the Cullens, putting him in a tough spot.

Background

With the Twilight series enjoying great financial success, Summit decided to follow in Harry Potter’s footsteps and split the final book into two films. Hired to helm both parts was Bill Condon, an Oscar-winning screenwriter best known for directing Dreamgirls and writing the screenplay for Chicago, yet with no previous background in visual-effect-driven films or romances. In an introductory letter to fans of the books, Condon reassured them that he was doing his homework, studying Catherine Hardwicke’s production notebook, listening to the soundtracks, and rewatching the earlier films (such admirable commitment to his craft!). Fans were pleased with the result as Breaking Dawn – Part 1 proved just as commercially successful as its predecessors, with women making up 80% of its opening-weekend audience. Critics were considerably less enthusiastic, giving the film the lowest Rotten Tomatoes score of the franchise. It went on to earn eight Razzie nominations.

The Review

Condon clearly understood the assignment and set out to make exactly the movie fans of the books wanted. Within seconds, Jacob is shirtless and running in the rain. Much of the first hour focuses on Bella’s anxiety about getting married and, later, losing her virginity. Since the film adapts only half a book, it has time to stick closely to the source material and even adds a climactic fight, something Condon would take even further in the second part. With that, we have a film that takes everything that was bad, awkward, and problematic in the previous films and doubles down on it.

All the franchise’s trademarks are here. We get dialogue worthy of a parody (“It’s their most absolute law,” “If you kill her, you kill me,” or the classic, “EJ. Edward Jacob”), terribly choreographed and shot action scenes (pay attention to the way some of the vampires move in the climactic fight against the wolves!), and so many cringeworthy sequences involving the love triangle. Bella continues to have far more chemistry with Jacob than with the extremely boring, emo Edward, with all his self-destructive, self-pitying behavior.

Making matters worse is how sincerely the movie plays some of the most troubling material from the book. After her first night with Edward, Bella wakes up with bruises, and somehow she’s the one who has to make him feel better. This is a franchise about a hundred-year-old vampire falling in love with a seventeen-year-old, one that has always treated possessiveness as the ultimate sign of love, and yet even that hardly compares with Jacob falling in love with a newborn baby. Can you imagine the girl going through school and college with the brooding, awkward wolf boy constantly watching over her? Meanwhile, the movie seems to have strong opinions about waiting until marriage to have sex and about abortion, although it has unsurprisingly little to say about either.

The performances range from checked out (Stewart and Pattinson) to trying far too hard (Lautner, the rest of the wolf pack, and the whole Cullen family). Stewart and Pattinson do give their all, trying to say their lines without laughing (Pattinson appears to fail at one point). The only actor who completely gets the assignment is Michael Sheen, who, in his brief appearance during the end credits, treats the material with all the over-the-top ridiculousness it deserves.

There are a few other (very small) positives. Carter Burwell returns after scoring the first film and finally gets to develop his tender theme, “Bella’s Lullaby,” while giving the wolf pack scenes the kind of symphonic force that deserves a far better film. The visual effects used to make Kristen Stewart look thin and sick are seamless, and the body horror goes further than you’d expect from this franchise. Still, these are very small positives compared to how laughably bad everything surrounding them is, from the music video-like montages to the melodramatic lines to the completely boring, unsuspenseful threat.

Final Thoughts

Breaking Dawn – Part 1 is the lowest point of the Twilight saga, an extremely slow film with troubling ideas of romance that somehow manages to be both ridiculous and devoid of fun. It’s tailor-made for fans who may see themselves in Bella’s insecurities, but for everyone else, it’s simply torturous.

At a glance
0.5/5
“PROBLEMATIC”
#6 of 6 in 2011 Movies RankedSee the ranking →
Original title
The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn – Part 1
Director
Bill Condon
Where to watch
Disney+NetflixCrave
Where to watch
Prime VideoGloboplayTelecine
Cast
Kristen Stewart, Robert Pattinson, Taylor Lautner, Billy Burke, Peter Facinelli, Michael Sheen, Elizabeth Reaser, Kellan Lutz
Rated
PG-13
Crew and more details
Screenwriter
Melissa Rosenberg, Rick Newsome
Composer
Carter Burwell
Cinematography
Guillermo Navarro
Editor
Virginia Katz
Country
Language
English
Budget
$110 million
Box office
$712.172 million
Trailer
Play trailer