There are always bad movies at TIFF. At the 50th edition of the festival, three in particular left me particularly frustrated and bothered. Charlie Harper presented its story and conflicts but avoided saying anything about its themes. Eleanor the Great twisted itself into knots to justify the terrible actions of its protagonist. And now Bad Apples, which somehow combines the weaknesses of both, completely misguided and yet still too afraid to truly say what it seems to be saying. It is the better of the three, with more entertaining passages and a tighter presentation, but even so it leaves audiences asking, “are we really doing this?” only for the film to answer, “no, never mind.”
In the film, the always fantastic Saoirse Ronan plays Maria, a primary school teacher whose class is constantly disrupted by one truly impossible student, Danny. No one knows what to do with him. He ignores authority, his father cannot contain him, and his violent behavior affects everyone around him. After one especially bad incident, Maria makes a drastic and impulsive decision: she kidnaps him and locks him in her basement. From that point on, the classroom thrives, and even Danny himself begins to show signs of improvement under her direct, if twisted, attention.
The setup promises a dark and thorny conversation, something not far from the themes explored in Netflix’s Adolescence. But imagine that series stripped of any of its complexities, resulting in the most barren version possible of that conversation. The film has absolutely nothing of note to say about its dilemma, nor about the morality of Maria’s choice. Whenever a scene edges toward real debate, it quickly pulls away. Instead, the film uses the premise for quick diversions, mostly from a young girl who might be even worse than Danny, or sequences where Maria is nearly caught. These moments can be mildly entertaining, especially because Ronan makes them watchable. The way the actress portrays her character debating whether to go through with a request is especially enjoyable. She is far above the material, but still does her best to elevate it. The pace also works in the film’s favor. It moves quickly from one incident to the next, escalating the stakes just enough to distract from how little is going on underneath.
By the end, though, the flaws are unavoidable. Bad Apples may be amusing in bursts, but it is ultimately deeply misguided. It pretends to stage serious conversations about morality and social responsibility, but its perspective is shallow and evasive. For me, it joins Eleanor the Great and I Don’t Understand You as part of 2025’s miscalculated trilogy, films hiding their rotten and crude cores behind a veneer of quirk. Good Boy, which screened at TIFF as well, tackled similar themes with far more conviction while also delivering genuine genre thrills. Bad Apples never reaches that level, leaving behind a film that entertains in the moment but leaves an extremely sour taste in your mouth.
This is part of Reviews On Reels TIFF 2025 Coverage. Due to the hectic rhythm of a film festival, it may be tweaked in the future. Still courtesy of TIFF.
Still courtesy of Republic Pictures
- Original title
- Bad Apples
- Director
- Jonatan Etzler
- Where to watch
- Rent or buy at Apple TV Store, Amazon Video
- Where to watch
- Not available for streaming
- Cast
- Saoirse Ronan, Eddie Waller, Nia Brown, Jacob Anderson, Rakie Ayola, Sean Gilder, Robert Emms, Kerry Howard
- Rated
- 14A
Crew and more details
- Screenwriter
- Jess O'Kane, Jonatan Etzler
- Composer
- Chris Roe
- Cinematography
- Nea Asphäll
- Editor
- Robert Krantz
- Country
- Language
- English
- Distributor (CA)
- Republic Pictures
Play trailer
- 1Everytime
- 2Hadestown: The Musical
- 3Minotaur
- 4You Can See Everything
- 5Hope
- 218Bad Apples#218 of 231
- 1Sentimental Value
- 2Hamnet
- 3Blue Moon
- 4Sirāt
- 5The Testament of Ann Lee
- 71Bad Apples#71 of 74




