Don’t read Homer’s Odyssey in The Return’s synopsis and expect a film brimming with epic battles, thrilling sword duels, or sweeping grandeur. On the contrary, this is a slow-burning, intimate reimagining of the epic’s ending. The film focuses on Odysseus’s homecoming to Ithaca after years of war and wandering, only to find his home overrun by suitors vying for his wife Penelope’s hand. While the original tale builds to a dramatic and triumphant confrontation, The Return opts for a restrained portrayal of longing, resilience, and the quiet devastation of time lost.
This minimalist approach finds its greatest strength in the casting of its two leads. Ralph Fiennes delivers a poignant performance as Odysseus, embodying the weariness of a man haunted by his long absence and the emotional toll of his journey. Juliette Binoche is equally captivating as Penelope, portraying her sorrow and quiet strength with grace. Their chemistry, rekindled from their earlier collaboration in The English Patient, anchors the film and lends emotional depth to its most compelling moments.
However, the film’s narrow scope comes at a cost. Its modest scale often feels more confining than intimate, leaving key elements unexplored. The suitors’ fierce competition for Penelope’s hand, for instance, feels hollow. Binoche is radiant as an older Penelope, but the film fails to convey why the suitors fight so desperately for her beyond her beauty. Without a clearer sense of what ruling Ithaca entails or why Penelope is so coveted, the stakes feel shallow, and the central conflict lacks urgency.
Charlie Plummer’s portrayal of Telemachus compounds the disconnect. His modern mannerisms and youthful appearance clash with the film’s historical tone, further weakening the narrative’s authenticity. The small-scale sets and chamber-like score, while intended to create intimacy, instead amplify the film’s tediousness. What could have been a richly layered exploration of loyalty, power, and identity instead feels stagnant, weighed down by its restrained ambition.
Yet, The Return finds moments of emotional resonance, particularly in its final act, where Odysseus must rise to a challenge that tests his resolve. This sequence injects much-needed energy, ending the film on a relatively strong note. However, despite its highlights, The Return ultimately feels too subdued and constrained to leave a lasting impression, relying heavily on its lead performances to carry the weight of an otherwise unremarkable narrative.
- Where to watch
Crave- Where to watch
Telecine
Play trailer
- Original title
- The Return
- Director
- Uberto Pasolini
- Cast
- Ralph Fiennes, Juliette Binoche, Charlie Plummer, Marwan Kenzari, Claudio Santamaria, Ángela Molina, Nikitas Tsakiroglou, Tom Rhys Harries
- Rated
- R
- Screenwriter
- Edward Bond, John Collee, Uberto Pasolini
- Composer
- Rachel Portman
- Cinematography
- Marius Panduru
- Editor
- David Charap
- Country
- Language
- English
- Budget
- $20 million
- Box office
- $3.3 million