Transformers One

Set on the metallic planet of Cybertron, Transformers One explores the origins of the conflict between Optimus Prime and Megatron. While critics and fans have praised its focus on the robots’ story without human characters, as well as the visuals and star-studded voice cast, featuring Chris Hemsworth, Brian Tyree Henry, and Scarlett Johansson, this portrayal may be one of the most lackluster representations of the iconic toys in any media, which is saying a lot given the existence of Michael Bay’s films.

Marking the first animated Transformers feature in theaters since 1986, the film takes more inspiration from those early animations than from recent live-action adaptations. Directed by Josh Cooley (Toy Story 4), the movie feels like it has absorbed all the worst traits of post-Endgame Marvel films: dull cinematography, washed-out tones, and far too many juvenile jokes. Cybertron comes across as lifeless and uninviting, and despite being an origin story, it misses the chance to explain why the robots transform into vehicles, something that would have added much-needed depth. The film struggles to establish a distinct world, with the robots acting too much like humans, which feels out of place in such an uninspiring setting. There’s a brief spark of creativity in its moving train with self-building rails, but that’s about as innovative as it gets.

The movie centers on the friendship and eventual fallout between Optimus Prime and Megatron, but it rushes through important moments, compressing the entire story into a brisk 90 minutes. Megatron’s bloodthirstiness is conveyed in a nearly laughable way, while Optimus Prime feels like a bland, conflict-free hero. Key twists are telegraphed within the first five minutes, and the characters spout simplistic lines like “If we don’t die doing this, I’ll kill you,” or “I didn’t do this for me, I did it for us.” Scaling back the roles of the irritating B-127 (future Bumblebee) and Elita-1 could have allowed more time to develop the relationship between Orion Pax and D-16, which would have also helped tone down the excessive attempts at humor.

The character designs, especially the faces, are uninspired and repetitive, while the action scenes, usually a highlight for Transformers fans, suffer from a dark and murky presentation, making them hard to follow. Brian Tyler’s score replaces the franchise’s powerful themes with a loud, generic orchestral sound that overwhelms rather than enhances. Though some praised the voice performances, I couldn’t shake the feeling that I was just listening to famous actors rather than getting immersed in the story.

Transformers One feels torn between appealing to children and satisfying older fans. Its simple story and dialogue seem geared toward younger viewers, yet it includes graphic scenes of robots being ripped apart. Themes like government corruption and betrayal are touched upon, but they feel tired and underdeveloped.

Ultimately, Transformers One may connect with die-hard fans of the animated series, but it offers little to engage newcomers or casual audiences. Instead of delivering an engaging origin story, it feels like a missed opportunity, a clunky, visually dull experience that’s hard to sit through and lacks the spark needed to bring these iconic characters to life.

At a glance

1/5

Skip it

Where to watch

🎟️Buy or rentparamount plus

Trailer

Play trailer

If you liked this

‹ ›

Wallace & Gromit: Vengeance Most Fowl

★★★★★

Arco

★★★★★

Toy Story 5

★★★★★

The Rescuers

★★★★★

Dune: Part Two

★★★★★